All American Girls

at the Actors Temple Theatre

Reviewed by David Sheward

August 27, 2010


Photo by David Wendell Boykins
Layon Gray has a potentially gripping subject in "All American Girls": the formation of an African-American women's baseball team in the segregated 1940s. He could have deeply explored issues of race, women's roles, and wartime social change. Instead, he settles for a melodramatic murder mystery that borrows a bit too much from another play.

During World War II, when it was feared the ranks of major league baseball would be diminished due to the draft, a women's league was formed. Just as with the male teams, there was a strict color barrier. While the male African-American players were at least able to play in the famous Negro leagues—albeit for lower wages and much less recognition than their white counterparts—talented black female players were almost totally frozen out. But there was a brief attempt at giving them an opportunity to play, when a single African-American female team was organized for an exhibition game against one of the white women's clubs.

Gray does give voice to black rage and frustration in a short scene when Jonetta, one of the players, threatens to quit because she feels she and her teammates are being exploited by the white management. In a passionate speech that contains echoes of August Wilson's "Fences," Jonetta rails against a system that keeps players of superior ability off the field just because of their skin color.

Apart from this one segment, Gray follows a whodunit template that too closely resembles that of "A Soldier's Play." Just like Charles Fuller's Pulitzer Prize–winning drama, "Girls" centers on the murder of a hard-assed authority figure (here it's the team coach rather than the platoon sergeant), which is investigated by a plucky outsider. Both plays make extended use of flashbacks. Gray does throw in a variation on Fuller's plot—a hokey device involving split personality—but it elicits inappropriate audience laughter.

Fortunately, Gray gives his script a tight staging, and most of the cast get as far as first base. Chantal Nchako gives Jonetta's plea for dignity a gritty intensity, and Catherine Peoples finds spunky humor in Eddie, the overly enthusiastic catcher. There are also strong contributions from Antoinette Robertson, Ashley Jeffrey, Yasha Jackson, Mari White, Daphnee Duplaix, and Setor E. Attipoe. As the rough-edged Coach Hicks, Arlene A. McGruder hits a home run. She takes the somewhat clichéd material Gray has pitched her and knocks it out of the park with a fierce attack, powerfully portraying a woman determined to overcome the obstacles of race and gender.



Presented by the Layon Gray Experience, the Black Gents of Hollywood, and Edmund Gaynes at the Actors Temple Theatre, 339 W. 47th St., NYC. Aug. 25–Oct. 28. Wed., 8 p.m.; Thu., 7 p.m. (212) 239-6200, (800) 432-7250, or www.telecharge.com. Casting by Karrie Moore.
 

 
Subscribe to Back Stage

More Off Broadway

Mariela

NY Review: 'Mariela en el Desierto (Mariela in the Desert)'
Zulema Clares' masterful portrayal of a woman who puts her family ahead of her art breathes life into Karen Zacarías... More »

    ADVERTISEMENT

    Unscripted Blog


    View Other Blogs »       Visit Unscripted »

    Sponsors

    Back Stage Video

    Duncan Stewart, director of casting at National Artists Management Company, talks about opening every submission and what he wants to see in a headshot.; casting; Duncan Stewart; headshot; new york city; open submissions; Duncan Steward, director of casting, talks about what he wants from an actor in a general meeting, mainly truth, likability, and lack of ego.; advice; casting; Duncan Stewart; new york city; tips; Duncan Stewart, director of casting, talks about what he expects from an audition and common mistakes actors make.; advice; auditions; casting; Duncan Stewart; new york city; Alaine Alldaffer breaks down the real role of a casting direcor.; Alaine Alldaffer; casting; casting director; Grey Gardens; play; stage; theater; Casting director Alaine Alldaffer talks about casting "Saved" and all the misconceptions about being an actor in New York City.; Alaine Alldaffer; casting director; NYC theatre; play; saved; NY casting director Bernie Telsey describes what actors need to know before walking into an audition. (Part 1 of 2) ; Bernie Telsey; casting director; We spoke with casting director Mark Teschner about working on soap operas. (Part 1 of 3) ; General Hospital; Mark Teschner; soap opera; NY casting director Bernie Telsey describes how to give your best audition. (Part 2 of 2) ; Bernie Telsey; casting director; We spoke with casting director Mark Teschner about working on soap operas. Need only beautiful people apply? (Part 2 of 3) ; General Hospital; Mark Teshner; soap opera; We spoke with casting director Mark Teschner about auditioning for soap operas. (Part 3 of 3) ; General Hospital; Mark Teschner; soap opera; Videos for the Back Stage News & Features section.

    Events Calendar

    ADVERTISEMENT